Tubs vs. Showers in NYC: Which Is Right for Your Space?

When renovating a bathroom in New York City, one of the most important design decisions you’ll face is whether to install a bathtub, a walk-in shower, or a combination of both. Each option has its own set of advantages depending on your space, lifestyle, and long-term goals.

In 2025, NYC homeowners are looking for solutions that are efficient, elegant, and resale-conscious. So—how do you choose the right one for your space?

Let’s break it down.

🛁 The Case for Bathtubs

Why Choose a Tub?

Bathtubs are classic, luxurious, and versatile — especially if you enjoy soaking after a long day or have young children at home.

Pros:

Ideal for family households with small children
Adds a luxurious, spa-like feel when paired with deep soaking or freestanding styles
Often considered a must-have in primary bathrooms for high-end resale appeal
Great for resale in larger apartments or brownstones

Cons:

Takes up more space
Longer fill and cleaning times
May feel underutilized if not regularly used

Best For:
Homeowners with space to spare or those seeking a tranquil, spa-style retreat in their bathroom.

👉 Explore spa-inspired bathroom ideas for NYC »

Spa-inspired bathroom renovation featuring a spacious design with a freestanding bathtub, walk-in shower and large windows | Tubs vs. Showers in NYC: Which Is Right for Your Space? | DCON Renovations New York - Brooklyn | Remodeling - Architectural Design - Residential Contractor - Brownstoner Experts

Bathtubs are classic, luxurious, and versatile — especially if you enjoy soaking after a long day or have young children at home.

🚿 The Case for Walk-In Showers

Why Choose a Shower?

Walk-in showers are sleek, space-saving, and perfect for fast-paced NYC lifestyles. In 2025, they’re also more customizable than ever.

Pros:

Maximizes space in smaller bathrooms
Easier to access and clean
Ideal for aging in place or multi-generational households
Offers modern, open-concept designs with glass or curbless entries
Can incorporate niches, benches, and luxury features like steam or dual showerheads

Cons:

May deter buyers with children if it’s the only bathing option
Can reduce resale appeal if your home has no tub at all

Best For:
Busy professionals, small-space dwellers, or homeowners prioritizing accessibility and modern aesthetics.

👉 View our expert walk-in shower tile guide »

Elegant modern bathroom remodel with wood floating vanity | Tubs vs. Showers in NYC: Which Is Right for Your Space? | DCON Renovations New York - Brooklyn | Remodeling - Architectural Design - Residential Contractor - Brownstoner Experts

Walk-in showers are sleek, space-saving, and perfect for fast-paced NYC lifestyles.

🧠 Key Factors to Consider in NYC Homes

1. Bathroom Size & Layout

In studio or one-bedroom apartments, a walk-in shower can open up the space dramatically.
In larger apartments or brownstones, consider keeping at least one tub for resale value.

2. Your Lifestyle

Daily soaker? A tub is your sanctuary.
Need speed and simplicity? Walk-in showers are your best bet.
Multigenerational family or accessibility concerns? Curbless showers win.

3. Resale Value

NYC real estate agents often advise keeping at least one tub in the home, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.
High-end buyers typically expect a tub in primary or guest bathrooms, especially in townhouses or condos over 2 bedrooms.

👉 Check out our guide: How Much Does a Luxury Bathroom Remodel Cost in NYC?

Spa-inspired bathroom design with oversized walk-in shower and stunning pendant lights | Tubs vs. Showers in NYC: Which Is Right for Your Space? | DCON Renovations New York - Brooklyn | Remodeling - Architectural Design - Residential Contractor - Brownstoner Experts

NYC real estate agents often advise keeping at least one tub in the home, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.

🏙️ NYC-Specific Design Tips

In small Manhattan apartments: Consider a tub/shower combo with a sliding glass panel for versatility
In Brooklyn brownstones: A walk-in shower in one bathroom and a freestanding tub in another adds balance
In luxury condos: Frameless showers with steam features or soaking tubs with city views are on trend for 2025

Final Thoughts

In the tub vs. shower debate, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It comes down to space, lifestyle, and what features matter most to you now — and to future buyers down the line.

At DCON Renovations, we help NYC homeowners craft bathrooms that blend luxury, function, and long-term value. Whether you’re dreaming of a freestanding tub, a modern walk-in shower, or a combination of both, we bring the design-build expertise to make it happen.

🚿 Book a consultation to find the perfect bathroom solution for your NYC home »