Tubs vs. Showers in NYC: Which Is Right for Your Space?
When renovating a bathroom in New York City, one of the most important design decisions you’ll face is whether to install a bathtub, a walk-in shower, or a combination of both. Each option has its own set of advantages depending on your space, lifestyle, and long-term goals.
In 2025, NYC homeowners are looking for solutions that are efficient, elegant, and resale-conscious. So—how do you choose the right one for your space?
Let’s break it down.
🛁 The Case for Bathtubs
Why Choose a Tub?
Bathtubs are classic, luxurious, and versatile — especially if you enjoy soaking after a long day or have young children at home.
Pros:
- Ideal for family households with small children
- Adds a luxurious, spa-like feel when paired with deep soaking or freestanding styles
- Often considered a must-have in primary bathrooms for high-end resale appeal
- Great for resale in larger apartments or brownstones
Cons:
- Takes up more space
- Longer fill and cleaning times
- May feel underutilized if not regularly used
Best For:
Homeowners with space to spare or those seeking a tranquil, spa-style retreat in their bathroom.
👉 Explore spa-inspired bathroom ideas for NYC »
Bathtubs are classic, luxurious, and versatile — especially if you enjoy soaking after a long day or have young children at home.
🚿 The Case for Walk-In Showers
Why Choose a Shower?
Walk-in showers are sleek, space-saving, and perfect for fast-paced NYC lifestyles. In 2025, they’re also more customizable than ever.
Pros:
- Maximizes space in smaller bathrooms
- Easier to access and clean
- Ideal for aging in place or multi-generational households
- Offers modern, open-concept designs with glass or curbless entries
- Can incorporate niches, benches, and luxury features like steam or dual showerheads
Cons:
- May deter buyers with children if it’s the only bathing option
- Can reduce resale appeal if your home has no tub at all
Best For:
Busy professionals, small-space dwellers, or homeowners prioritizing accessibility and modern aesthetics.
Walk-in showers are sleek, space-saving, and perfect for fast-paced NYC lifestyles.
🧠 Key Factors to Consider in NYC Homes
1. Bathroom Size & Layout
- In studio or one-bedroom apartments, a walk-in shower can open up the space dramatically.
- In larger apartments or brownstones, consider keeping at least one tub for resale value.
2. Your Lifestyle
- Daily soaker? A tub is your sanctuary.
- Need speed and simplicity? Walk-in showers are your best bet.
- Multigenerational family or accessibility concerns? Curbless showers win.
3. Resale Value
- NYC real estate agents often advise keeping at least one tub in the home, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.
- High-end buyers typically expect a tub in primary or guest bathrooms, especially in townhouses or condos over 2 bedrooms.
👉 Check out our guide: How Much Does a Luxury Bathroom Remodel Cost in NYC?
NYC real estate agents often advise keeping at least one tub in the home, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods.
🏙️ NYC-Specific Design Tips
- In small Manhattan apartments: Consider a tub/shower combo with a sliding glass panel for versatility
- In Brooklyn brownstones: A walk-in shower in one bathroom and a freestanding tub in another adds balance
- In luxury condos: Frameless showers with steam features or soaking tubs with city views are on trend for 2025
Final Thoughts
In the tub vs. shower debate, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It comes down to space, lifestyle, and what features matter most to you now — and to future buyers down the line.
At DCON Renovations, we help NYC homeowners craft bathrooms that blend luxury, function, and long-term value. Whether you’re dreaming of a freestanding tub, a modern walk-in shower, or a combination of both, we bring the design-build expertise to make it happen.
🚿 Book a consultation to find the perfect bathroom solution for your NYC home »
Recent Articles
Categories
- Apartment Renovation (29)
- Basement Renovation (7)
- Bathroom Remodeling (28)
- Brownstone Renovation (15)
- Design | Build (19)
- Eco-friendly Renovation (4)
- Exterior Renovations (4)
- Home Remodeling (20)
- Home Renovation (26)
- Interior Renovation (28)
- Kitchen Remodeling (24)
- Other (4)
